This is the whole point, and it is where most explanations stop too early. Mortgage interest is
normally a deduction: it reduces your taxable income, so you keep a fraction of
it depending on your bracket.
A mortgage credit certificate made part of that interest a credit — a
dollar-for-dollar reduction of what you actually owe. The certificate rate was
25% of the mortgage interest you paid that year, capped at
$2,000 a year, claimed annually for the life of the first mortgage on
IRS Form 8396, Mortgage Interest Credit.
You did not receive it at closing. Nothing appeared on your closing disclosure. That is precisely
why so many buyers never knew it existed — it arrived years later, in your tax return, every
year.